TY - JOUR
T1 - Retraction note
T2 - Verteporfin-induced formation of protein cross-linked oligomers and high molecular weight complexes is mediated by light and leads to cell toxicity (Scientific Reports, (2017), 7, 1, (46581), 10.1038/srep46581)
AU - Konstantinou, Eleni K.
AU - Notomi, Shoji
AU - Kosmidou, Cassandra
AU - Brodowska, Katarzyna
AU - Al-Moujahed, Ahmad
AU - Nicolaou, Fotini
AU - Tsoka, Pavlina
AU - Gragoudas, Evangelos
AU - Miller, Joan W.
AU - Young, Lucy H.
AU - Vavvas, Demetrios G.
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Publisher 2024.
PY - 2024/12
Y1 - 2024/12
N2 - Retraction of: Scientific Reportshttps://doi.org/10.1038/srep46581, published online 21 April 2017 The Editors have retracted this Article. After publication it was brought to the Editors’ attention that a number of the western blot images appear similar to each other, specifically: Figure 1B “dark (tx) & Light (lysis)” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 beta-actin; Figure 1B “dark” MCF-7 Diap1 appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 and MCF-7 Diap1; Figure 1B “dark” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1B “dark” KEK 293 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 0h time point MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” 0h time point Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 6h time point MEL 270 Rock1 appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” Diap1 6h time point; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to “dark” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B p62 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 appears similar to Figure 3A “MEL 270” Diap1 last 3 lanes; Figure 3A “Mel 270” p62 appears similar to Mel 270 p62 beta-actin; Figure 3A “MCF-7” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 4 “Hek 293” top beta-actin appears similar to “Hek 293” bottom beta-actin; Figure 4 “MCF-7” top beta-actin appears similar to “MCF-7” bottom beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” YAP1 appears similar to YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “light” YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” p-YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6A “light” p-YAP1 appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP; Figure 6C "light" YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 6B "light" p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” p62 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MEL 270” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin. Figure 1B “dark (tx) & Light (lysis)” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 beta-actin; Figure 1B “dark” MCF-7 Diap1 appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 and MCF-7 Diap1; Figure 1B “dark” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1B “dark” KEK 293 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 0h time point MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” 0h time point Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 6h time point MEL 270 Rock1 appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” Diap1 6h time point; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to “dark” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B p62 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 appears similar to Figure 3A “MEL 270” Diap1 last 3 lanes; Figure 3A “Mel 270” p62 appears similar to Mel 270 p62 beta-actin; Figure 3A “MCF-7” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 4 “Hek 293” top beta-actin appears similar to “Hek 293” bottom beta-actin; Figure 4 “MCF-7” top beta-actin appears similar to “MCF-7” bottom beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” YAP1 appears similar to YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “light” YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” p-YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6A “light” p-YAP1 appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP; Figure 6C "light" YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 6B "light" p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” p62 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MEL 270” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin. The Authors are unable to provide the original raw data underlying these figures. The Editors therefore no longer have confidence in the results and conclusions reported. Eleni K. Konstantinou, Shoji Notomi, Ahmad Al-Moujahed, Fotini Nicolaou, Pavlina Tsoka, Evangelos Gragoudas, Joan W. Miller, Lucy H. Young and Demetrios Vavvas agree with this retraction and its wording. The Editors were not able to find a current email address for Cassandra Kosmidou and Katarzyna Brodowska.
AB - Retraction of: Scientific Reportshttps://doi.org/10.1038/srep46581, published online 21 April 2017 The Editors have retracted this Article. After publication it was brought to the Editors’ attention that a number of the western blot images appear similar to each other, specifically: Figure 1B “dark (tx) & Light (lysis)” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 beta-actin; Figure 1B “dark” MCF-7 Diap1 appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 and MCF-7 Diap1; Figure 1B “dark” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1B “dark” KEK 293 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 0h time point MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” 0h time point Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 6h time point MEL 270 Rock1 appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” Diap1 6h time point; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to “dark” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B p62 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 appears similar to Figure 3A “MEL 270” Diap1 last 3 lanes; Figure 3A “Mel 270” p62 appears similar to Mel 270 p62 beta-actin; Figure 3A “MCF-7” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 4 “Hek 293” top beta-actin appears similar to “Hek 293” bottom beta-actin; Figure 4 “MCF-7” top beta-actin appears similar to “MCF-7” bottom beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” YAP1 appears similar to YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “light” YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” p-YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6A “light” p-YAP1 appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP; Figure 6C "light" YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 6B "light" p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” p62 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MEL 270” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin. Figure 1B “dark (tx) & Light (lysis)” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 beta-actin; Figure 1B “dark” MCF-7 Diap1 appears similar to Figure 1C “dark” HEK-293 and MCF-7 Diap1; Figure 1B “dark” MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 1B “dark” KEK 293 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 0h time point MEL 270 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” 0h time point Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 1C “dark (tx) and light (lysis)” 6h time point MEL 270 Rock1 appears similar to Figure 7 “MEL 270” Diap1 6h time point; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to “dark” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B p62 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 beta-actin appears similar to Fig 3B Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 2 “light” Rock1 appears similar to Figure 3A “MEL 270” Diap1 last 3 lanes; Figure 3A “Mel 270” p62 appears similar to Mel 270 p62 beta-actin; Figure 3A “MCF-7” Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 4 “Hek 293” top beta-actin appears similar to “Hek 293” bottom beta-actin; Figure 4 “MCF-7” top beta-actin appears similar to “MCF-7” bottom beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “dark” YAP1 appears similar to YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6B “light” YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 6C “light” p-YAP1 beta-actin; Figure 6A “light” p-YAP1 appears similar to Figure 6C “light” YAP; Figure 6C "light" YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” Diap1 beta-actin; Figure 6B "light" p-YAP1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” p62 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MEL 270” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “HEK 293” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin; Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Diap1 beta-actin appears similar to Figure 7 “MCF-7” 6h time point Rock1 beta-actin. The Authors are unable to provide the original raw data underlying these figures. The Editors therefore no longer have confidence in the results and conclusions reported. Eleni K. Konstantinou, Shoji Notomi, Ahmad Al-Moujahed, Fotini Nicolaou, Pavlina Tsoka, Evangelos Gragoudas, Joan W. Miller, Lucy H. Young and Demetrios Vavvas agree with this retraction and its wording. The Editors were not able to find a current email address for Cassandra Kosmidou and Katarzyna Brodowska.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85193204723&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85193204723&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1038/s41598-024-61893-8
DO - 10.1038/s41598-024-61893-8
M3 - Comment/debate
C2 - 38744880
AN - SCOPUS:85193204723
SN - 2045-2322
VL - 14
JO - Scientific reports
JF - Scientific reports
IS - 1
M1 - 11040
ER -